Dr. ALFREDA WITHINGTON

Pine Mountain Settlement School
Series 09: Staff/Personnel

Dr. ALFREDA WITHINGTON

Medical Settlement Physician 1924 – 1931
big_laurel_3369

“Billy” was Alfreda’s faithful companion during her seven years at the Big Laurel Medical Settlement.


TAGS: Alfreda Withington ; social service ; Big Laurel Medical Settlement ; Hicksite Quaker School ; Cornell University ; Women’s Medical College of NY ; Elizabeth Blackwell ; Zurich, Switzerland ; NY Infirmary for Women and Children ; Women’s Medical Hospital of New York  ; hospitals ; medical practices ; general medical practitioners ; Mission of the Deep Sea Fisherman ; Labrador ; Franco-American Dispensary ; Hospital at Dreux France ; Dr. Wilfred T. Grenfell ;  Tuberculosis Hospital ; American National Red Cross ; Medical Settlement Big Laurel ; Harlan County ; Greasy Creek ; horseback riding ; diphtheria ; Cora Craig ; Dr. Eizabeth Blackwell ; Dr. Grace Huse


Alfreda Bosworth Withington was born in 1861. In the early 1900s, it took a woman of great courage, persistence, resourcefulness, and tact to become a medical doctor. And a very intrepid and experienced doctor to qualify for the above advertisement posted in a medical journal by the founders of the new Pine Mountain Settlement School. Such a person was Dr. Alfreda Bosworth Withington, who, at the end of her long career, worked for seven years at one of the two Medical Settlements established by Katherine Pettit and Ethel de Long Zande, founders of Pine Mountain Settlement School.

In her memoir, Mine Eyes Have Seen (1941), Dr. Withington wrote that the goal of her parents was to provide her and her two brothers, George and James, with a good education. Her father (James Withington II), a principal of an academy in Hallowell, Maine, and later in Germantown, Pennsylvania, saw to it that the children grew up in a household full of books. Her mother, (nee Alfreda Bosworth), who missed her own chance to have an advanced education, influenced Alfreda to attend college. She also taught Alfreda “self-reliance and enterprise” and built in her “a steadying belief that obstacles could be overcome by will and perseverance,” attributes that enabled Alfreda to withstand the many adversities she faced throughout her career.

After attending the Hicksite Quaker School in Germantown, Pennsylvania, Alfreda was admitted in 1877 to the school that her brother George had attended, Cornell University in Ithaca, New York. There she earned a Bachelor of Arts degree in 1881. Alfreda had already lost a sister and then her father in 1877 to tuberculosis, when her beloved older brother and mentor, George, contracted the disease. The helplessness she felt as she cared for him before he died led to her decision to study medicine.

After postgraduate science studies at Cornell, Alfreda matriculated in 1883 from the Woman’s Medical College of the New York Infirmary, a small school founded by two women, Drs. Elizabeth and Emily Blackwell. [Elizabeth Blackwell, the first woman physician in the United States, began her interest in medicine while living in Asheville, NC, and went on to found the Woman’s Medical College of New York, one of two colleges in the East that provided high-quality medical education for women.] After graduation, Withington interned at the New York Infirmary for Women and Children, which, she wrote,

…not only gave me a wonderful opportunity for realizing that erudition without experience is of small value, but helped to broaden my understanding of human beings – an understanding essential to medical practice.

However, her application for a position with the Infirmary for Women and Children was rejected, as none of the male directors would agree to let her take the entrance examination. Disappointed at this rebuff, she took the advice of her mentor and traveled to Europe where she studied at various institutions in Vienna, Prague, Zurich, and Berlin. Again she was met with prejudice against women in the field of medicine but quietly persevered, often finding ways to work around rules or convince officials that she was capable and qualified. She learned enough of the language of each country to attend classes, watch the work of well-known physicians, and eventually perform surgery herself.

When Alfreda, now Dr. Withington, returned home she turned down offers of teaching positions in order to start her own practice. Her doctor recommended that she move to an eastern town with a high altitude that would help her manage the “slight trouble” in one of her lungs. By 1891, she had selected Pittsfield in the Berkshire Hills of Massachusetts. She thrived as a general practitioner in this small town, enjoying friendships with both colleagues and townspeople. Although by this time she had 15 years of surgical experience, she felt that her choice to serve as a general practitioner was the right one, stating,

To be close to patients, to enjoy their confidence, to share their anxieties, to be helpful, is very satisfying, and many by their endurance of suffering, by their courage in facing the inevitable, set an example never to be forgotten.

In 1906, Dr. Withington was in need of a restorative vacation and volunteered that summer as the first female doctor to work with Dr. Wilfred T. Grenfell, who founded the Mission of the Deep Sea Fisherman and established several hospitals and medical centers in Labrador. She was assigned to care for the “fisherfolk” of Blanc Sablon in Quebec, and later at Indian Harbor, Labrador. According to Dr. Grenfell writing in the introduction to her biography, Mine Eyes have Seen, “The Lady Doctor came, worked and conquered….”knew that he someone special on his staff. That was not always the case. Dr. Withington had to fight most of her life to have her gifts recognized by her fellow travelers, especially men. Grenfell, recognized her talents.

Back in Pittsfield, MA she joined with other doctors to establish a tuberculosis hospital and later helped form the Berkshire Chapter of the newly incorporated American National Red Cross. By 1917 World War I was in progress, and she volunteered for service in France as a tuberculosis specialist under the auspices of the Red Cross. While there, she was later transferred to the Rockefeller Commission to work among civilians.

After another four years of arduous work with the war’s wounded and sick in France where she served as the Chief of the Franco-American Dispensary and Hospital at Dreux, she was asked to work with the Rockefeller Commission among the war refugees and immigrants displaced by WWI.  After an attack of angina she returned to Pittsfield but was no longer comfortable with her former “conventional” practice after all that she had recently experienced. Finally, a friend pointed out an ad in the Journal of the American Medical Association, placed by Miss Pettit and Mrs. Zande, directors of the Pine Mountain Settlement School, seeking a “woman physician.”

Wanted, a woman physician for settlement work in the remote Kentucky mountains; all calls to be made on horseback, no other licensed physician within twenty-five miles.

Delighted that “[t]he time had come when a woman physician was wanted,” Dr. Withington put her concerns for her personal health aside, secured a Kentucky medical license and, in 1924 at the age of 63, she headed for the Kentucky mountains by train from Louisville to Laden Trail and on to Pine Mountain.  After an overnight at the School, she was introduced to a log cabin on the side of a mountain at Big Laurel Medical Settlement, on the headwaters of Greasy Creek, that was to be her home and office for the next seven years. Along with her staff: a nurse, welfare worker, and a “mountain girl,” she set about doing what she knew so very well, taking care of the sick. The nearest hospital, run by the U.S. Steel Corporation, was located in the mining town of Lynch, nearly 25 miles away. Serious charity cases were taken to Louisville using free passes from the Louisville and Nashville Railroad. To reach the train to Lynch or Louisville, a patient was carried on a stretcher over the mountain by a relay of men from the family and community.

Dr. Withington treated many of the deadly ailments that were common at that time in the mountains, such as tetanus, influenza, typhoid, trachoma, diphtheria, nephritis, pneumonia, and a chickenpox outbreak at Pine Mountain Settlement School. She was also kept busy with health concerns that seemed to be more prevalent in the mountains than elsewhere: hookworm and rheumatism. She and her nurse kept no regular office hours and spent much of their time traveling up and down steep trails on horseback to visit patients in their homes, all the while keeping an eye out for rattlesnakes, copperheads, stray farm animals, and bootleggers. The number of home deliveries of babies is not known but it was large. Many of the babies were named for her. 

On night riding to a call on the back of a borrowed horse, Maude, (her trusted horse, “Billy” was out of commission), she carefully made her way in the dark on an emergency call to the home of Cora Craig whose smallest child had fallen in the fire and was badly burned. Dr. Withington, fearing to leave the child unattended spent the night and then saddled Maude for the trip home. Going down one of the steep trails the horse stumbled and , she became the patient as she described it in her biography

“…I struck almost squarely on my face. I remember the sensation of hurtling through the air and hearing a crash. Then there was a blank.

A mountain woman was standing over me when I came to. I had an awareness that something was wrong; putting my hand to my nose I felt it crunch, and it was bleeding terribly. I told the woman to give me my kit, and lying there I manipulated the grating bones, straightened them, and poked some gauze up my nostrils. Though faint from loss of blood there was nothing for me to do but remount and ride the four miles home. ”

She got herself patched up and went to Louisville to see a specialist and found that her malar bones were not smashed but two days later she was confronted with all the signs of a typical diphtheria infection and that did keep her down for weeks. Upon her recovery, however, she came straight back to the mountains where she welcomed Spring

“I rode over mountainsides entirely covered with blue “woolly breeches,” and saw between the trees the hazy blue of the more distant Cumberland ridges. That was the tapestry that nature once more spread out before me.”

Despite the dangers and discomforts of her outings, she wrote lovingly about the mountains and their forests, creeks, cliffs, and wildlife, and described the beauty of rhododendron, dogwood, holly, and laurel that grew along the way. Her ease in mingling with the mountain people and her love and respect for them were evident in her writings, and she enjoyed various local gatherings and cultural events in her free time.

Alfreda Withington

Tea on the lawn at Zande House [Dogwood Breakfast ?] , 1930. (l. to r.) Sally Loomis, a visitor Miss Taylor, Dr. Alfreda Withington, Miss Burbrick, Mrs. Burns, Miss Melville, Mrs. Barti…, Miss McDavid, Mrs. Bo …X_100_workers_2541.jpg

In 1931, she traveled to Washington, D.C., for what she intended to be a short respite. However, another attack of angina prevented her from returning to the mountains. At the end of her memoir, Dr. Withington wrote:

It was a tugging at my heart that I realized my work was over. Life there was so real in its ruggedness and simplicity. I shall think often of the kindness and hospitality….

My memories are rich: student days with their discouragements and small successes; the Old World with its glimpses of unfamiliar people and ancient landmarks; the bleak shores of Labrador and her hardy, friendly people; the War with its tragedies and its heroisms and, strangely enough, its humors; the dense forests of the Kentucky Mountains and their simple folk threading the endless narrow trails. All these hundreds of men and women I have known, and in many cases ministered to, have given me back a thousandfold whatever I have given.

By 1941, when her memoir, Mine Eyes Have Seen, was published, she was still residing in Washington, D.C. Ten years later, on October 1, 1951, she died and was buried in Pittsfield, Massachusetts. In 1945, shortly after the publication of her memoir, Alfreda sent the following letter to Delia Creech, wife of Henry Creech and daughter-in-law of William and Sally Creech.

Dear Mrs. Creech,

I wonder how the summer has treated you. Mrs. Bullock [Katherine Pettit’s sister in Lexington] sent me a paper giving the hundredth anniversary celebration [actually 50th Anniversary?] It was very interesting – she seems to like the Benjamins as has everyone I’ve seen.

Are your son, who was in England, and Oma [Delia’s daughter who later became a doctor] still over there? — It will be a hard winter in Europe —

I was unfortunate enough to have to have an operation — was in the hospital from mid-October to mid-Nov. Am now settled here for the winter, but will require some weeks or months to get back my strength.

If you could send any rhododendron I wonder if you could get it away from where the railroad goes — The leaves were covered with a fine soot — and even though I washed each leaf carefully it had affected the green — I enjoyed it, however — but if it is just as easy to get it when it is clean it would be better. The sprays that shape are particularly nice. [Drawing]

I had a small parcel ready to send you when I went to the hospital but it is in a case not yet received — I shall be so interested to hear from you — I had hoped to see Miss Cobb in Boston but didn’t run across her.

Much love,

Alfreda Withington

_____________________________________________________________________________________

She also wrote the following letter [n.d.] to Delia Creech which appears to have been written after the one above and again refers to Oma, Delia’s daughter, whom she mentored and who later became a doctor.

Allerton House 130 East 57th Street New York 22, N.Y.

Dear Delia — I suppose by this time Oma has made her visit and how happy you must have been to see her. Where will she live and will she continue her practice? It would be a pity to give it up after all her experience —

I am writing especially to ask if there is still a P.O. at Big Laurel — I want to send Betts Lewis something. Will you let me know and also will you tell me if you received a small black and white scarf [drawing of scarf] in the box with the pin and beads. I ask simply to know if everything goes through all right.

Next year in the Spring or Fall I am going to clear out my storage and I have there a saddle. I last used it in Arizona, but I doubt if I [will] ride again. Would you like it? My riding habit is too small for you, but could some member of your family use it? This is inquiring a long way ahead but if I know just where to send the things it will be easier when the time comes.

I am back here [New York] for the winter but New York is jammed as usual — much confusion and yet it has certain comforts.

Affectionate greetings Alfreda Withington


SEE ALSO:

MEDICAL SETTLEMENT at BIG LAUREL

CREECH FAMILY LETTERS 1931

DR. GRACE HUSE

MEDICAL

GUIDE TO MEDICAL HEALTH & HYGIENE

GUIDE TO LINE FORK SETTLEMENT WORKERS REPORTS 1921 -1941

HARRIET WALKER

HARRIET BUTLER


Title

Alfreda Withington

Alt. Title

Alfreda Bosworth Withington

Identifier

ALFREDA WITHINGTON

Creator

Pine Mountain Settlement School, Pine Mountain, KY

Alt. Creator

Ann Angel Eberhardt ; Helen Hayes Wykle ;

Subject Keyword

Alfreda Withington ; Alfreda Bosworth Withington ; Pine Mountain Settlement School ; social service ; Katherine Pettit ; Ethel de Long ; Big Laurel Medical Settlement ; memoir ; James Withington II ; Hallowell, ME ; Germantown, PA ; Alfreda Bosworth ; Hicksite Quaker School ; Cornell University ; Ithaca, NY ; Women’s College of the NY Infirmary ; Elizabeth Blackwell ; Emily Blackwell ; NY Infirmary for Women and Children ; Women’s Hospital ; hospitals ; Vienna ; Prague ; Zurich ; Berlin ; medical practices ; general medical practitioners ; Pittsfield, MA ; Dr. Wilfred T. Grenfell ; Mission of the Deep Sea Fisherman ; Blanc Sablon, Quebec ; Indian Harbor, Labrador ; Tuberculosis Hospital ; American National Red Cross ; Berkshire Hills ; World War I ; France ; Rockefeller Commission ; American Medical Association ; Louisville, KY ; Laden Trail ; U.S. Steel Corporation ; Lynch, KY ; Washington, DC ; Philadelphia, PA ; New York, NY ; Boston, MA ; Arizona ; Delia Creech ; Henry Creech ; Mrs. Bullock ; The Benjamins ; Oma Creech ; Miss Cobb ; Betts Lewis ; Zande House ; Dogwood Breakfast(?) ; Sally Loomis, a visitor Miss Taylor ; Miss Burbrick ; Mrs. Burns, Miss Melville ; Miss McDavid ;

Subject LCSH

Withington, Alfreda Bosworth, — 1861 – 1951.
History of Medicine — Biography.
Pine Mountain Settlement School (Pine Mountain, Ky.) — History.
Big Laurel Medical Settlement (Big Laurel, Ky.) — History.
Harlan County (Ky.) — History.
Settlement Schools — Harlan County — Kentucky.
Women — Southern States — History.

Date

2004-06-26

Publisher

Pine Mountain Settlement School, Pine Mountain, KY

Contributor

Robert Leach

Type

Text ; image ;

Format

Original and copies of documents and correspondence in file folders in filing cabinet.

Source

Series 9: Staff/Personnel ; and Series 14B: Medical — Medical Settlement at Big Laurel

Language

English

Relation

Is related to: Pine Mountain Settlement School Collections, Series 9: Staff/Personnel and Series 14B: Medical — Medical Settlement at Big Laurel

Coverage Temporal

1861 – 1951

Coverage Spatial

Pine Mountain, KY ; Harlan County, KY ; Hallowell, ME ; Germantown, PA ; Ithaca, NY ; New York, NY ; Vienna, Austria ; Prague, Czechoslovakia ; Zurich, Switzerland ; Berlin, Germany ; Pittsfield, MA ; Blanc Sablon, Quebec ; Indian Harbor, Labrador ; Berkshire Hills, MA ; France ; Louisville, KY ; Lynch, KY ; Washington, DC ; Philadelphia, PA ; Boston, MA ; Arizona ;

Rights

Any display, publication, or public use must credit the Pine Mountain Settlement School, Pine Mountain, KY. Copyright retained by the creators of certain items in the collection, or their descendants, as stipulated by United States copyright law.

Donor

Robert Leach

Description

Core documents, correspondence, writings, and administrative papers created by or addressed to Alfreda Bosworth Withington ; clippings, photographs, albums, books by or about Alfreda Bosworth Withington ;

Acquisition

2013-11-06

Citation

“[Identification of Item],” [Collection Name] [Series Number, if applicable]. Pine Mountain Settlement School Institutional Papers. Pine Mountain Settlement School, Pine Mountain, KY.

Processed By

Helen Hayes Wykle ; Ann Angel Eberhardt ;

Last Updated

2007-06-28 hhw ; 2009-11-20 aae ; 2013-11-05 aae ; 2013-11-09 hhw ; 2017-03-07

Bibliography

Sources:

“Alfreda Withington,” Series 09: Staff/Personnel. Pine Mountain Settlement School Institutional Papers. Pine Mountain Settlement School, Pine Mountain, KY. Internet resource.

Writings by Dr. Withington:

Withington, Alfreda. Mine Eyes Have Seen: A Woman Doctor’s Saga. New York: E.P. Dutton & Co., Inc, 1941. Print. [Four editions were published between 1941 and 1945, including a London publication by R. Hale, 1945.]

Withington, Alfreda Bosworth. The Value of Caricature. Thesis (A. B.) Cornell University. May 1881. Print.

Withington, Alfreda Bosworth. The Mountain Doctor. Boston, 1932. Print.

Withington, Alfreda. “The Mountain Doctor [Part I].” Atlantic Monthly, 150:3 (September 1932) 257-267. Print.

Withington, Alfreda. “The Mountain Doctor [Part II].” Atlantic Monthly, 150:4 (October 1932) 469-477. Print.

Withington, Alfreda. “The Mountain Doctor [Part III].” Atlantic Monthly, 150:6 (December 1932) 768-774. Print.

Withington, Alfreda. Letters from Alfreda Withington to Delia Creech. Archival material.

Dr. Withington’s papers are included in these collections:

Clelia Duel Mosher Papers. Stanford, CA: Hoover Institution Archives, Stanford University. Box/Folder 2:23, 1919-1920. Online Archives of California: http://www.oac.cdlib.org (accessed 2009-10-30). Internet resource.

Gaffney, Patricia H. (Ed.), The Emily Howland Papers at Cornell University: A Guide to the Microfilm Publication, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Library Division of Rare and Manuscript Collections, Carl A. Kroch Library, 1975. Dr. Al. B. Withington: Reel 4, Mar 1891 – 1900. Archival material.

Dr. Withington is mentioned in the following publications:

Chin, Eliza L. This Side of Doctoring: Reflections from Women in Medicine. Thousand Oaks, Calif: Sage Publications, 2002. Print.

Kelly, Howard A. M.D. A Cyclopedia of American Medical Biography, Comprising the Lives of Eminent Deceased Physicians and Surgeons from 1610 to 1910, Volume 2. Philadelphia, PA: W.B. Saunders Company, 1912. Print.

“Withington Alfreda Bosworth: 77-83.” The Ten-Year Book of Cornell University. (1908). Print.

Return to: BIOGRAPHY – A-Z